Nov
19

Alabama Judges Supreme on Life or Death

By

The Supreme Court has tacitly approved a practice in Alabama that gives judges the authority to override jury decisions on the death penalty.  The Court turned away a case in which a trial judge had overturned the jury’s sentence of life without parole; he changed the sentence to death.

Judges have that authority under Alabama law, and the Supreme Court affirmed it.  There is a political component that Justice Sonia Sotomayor found disturbing: judges in law-and-order Alabama are elected, and are sensitive to the political winds.  Given choices of life or death, judges have chosen death by a margin of more than 10 to 1.  (95 changes of a life sentence to death; nine overrides of a death sentence to life.)

Sotomayor found only one explanation: “Alabama judges, who are elected in partisan proceedings, appear to have succumbed to electoral pressures.”

The Court refused to hear the Alabama appeal.  Sotomayor’s comments came in unusual public dissent of the turndown.

(More from an excellent Adam Liptak piece: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/us/alabama-judges-retain-the-right-to-override-juries-in-capital-sentencing.html)

Categories : Uncategorized

Comments are closed.

MOYERS


BILL MOYERS, journalist, author, and managing editor, Moyers & Company

“This book is a lightning strike. It quickens the mind, illuminates the landscape, and guarantees you will see things differently—in this case, how the jagged edges of justice come to bear on decisions of life and death. Clancy and O’Brien are journalists at the top of their class, where facts matter and reporting can read like a novel.”

WALTERS

BARBARA WALTERS, ABC News

“Takes the smoke screen out of the capital-punishment debate and dishes out the realities: the

challenges to judges and lawmakers posed by awful crimes, competing pressures on the scale of

justice, and the role of victims in determining punishment. A great read and more. . . . An

important book.”

TOOBIN

Jeffrey Toobin, writer for the New Yorker, legal analyst for CNN

“A thoughtful and fascinating look behind the headlines of some of the most grisly—and

important—murder cases at the Supreme Court."